This was a sweet story about Josie, the owner of a bed and breakfast, whose Christmas holiday is off to a crazy start with her friend having a heart attack in the middle a bridge game in her home. This reminder of the vulnerability of life triggers her to invite her estranged daughters to come home for Christmas, much to their surprise, and it invites a lot of nostalgia mixed with emotional eruptions.
I think I’d describe this book as benign; it’s a decent read, quick, keeps one’s interest, the characters are likable, the writing is passable – but there is nothing imaginative about it. I did not learn anything new from it. There was nothing culturally unusual about it.
I do find stories about relationships interesting – mother/daughter, wife/husband, generational conflicts, etc. This touches on some of this. But I found that some of this is left undone, or kept at the surface. There is never a deep unpacking of the deeper relationship or feelings. There is never the huge explosion that there should be when emotions run so high.
I was left wanting just a little bit more. And in this case, that was not a good thing…
After 24 years of marriage, Elizabeth has finally come to terms with the fact that her husband, Jack, and her 2 daughters have all taken center stage in her life, leaving her to cast aside her own dreams and aspirations. When Jack was a famous football star, she cared for her young daughters mostly by herself. When Jack later became a smaller time sports caster, moving from town to town where opportunities arose, she duly followed. But now that the girls are both out of the house, she realizes that it is time for her to attend to herself – she just has to figure out whether that plan will include Jack or not…
This is a story that will, sadly, strike a familiar chord with many readers, I believe. When the nest empties, it is often a challenge for couples to fill the void – or it is the time when the void has to finally be acknowledged. Hannah describes this conflict with sensitivity, honesty and warmth, presenting both Elizabeth’s and Jack’s sides to a complicated story.
I think it was not good that I knew before reading this book that the author had written The Nightingale. That book was so outstanding that I had elevated expectations for this one. For example, some subplots were hinted at but then left undone. One character, Kim, who Elizabeth met in a support group, was a mysterious, moodier member of the group. It appeared that she was going to be more of a presence in the book (and it was an interesting possibility), but she was just sort of abandoned in a more underdeveloped state.
I would still recommend this book – it was a nice read – but manage your expectations if you’ve read The Nightingale!
In this slightly outlandish story, Sophie finds herself sucked into the circumstances of her ex-boyfriend’s family, when his Aunt Connie has died and left her house on an island to Sophie. This is no ordinary island, however. It is on this island, where many years prior, Connie and her sister, Rose, walked into their neighbors’ house, expecting to have tea with their neighbors, Jack and Alice Munro, when they discovered their baby girl left unattended, with Jack and Alice having mysteriously vanished. Sophie herself remembers visiting the island, now a shrine of sorts (and the source of a healthy income for the sisters), where the rooms were left untouched, still with bloodstains and an unfinished crossword puzzle, just as if they’d just deserted the room that morning. As the events unfold, the family and their individual struggles and conflicts come to light and Sophie finds peace with her own life as she helps them with theirs.
As usual, Moriarty tells a tale that is alternatively amusing and tragic. While the premise is a little far-fetched, the struggles that these quirky characters are coping with – relationship issues, depression, child neglect and worse – are quite realistic. And Moriarty’s signature humor and warmth follow each character through to the end.
If you’re looking for a fun read with some substance, this is your book!
OK, I’ll admit I’m a little obsessed with the writing of Beatriz Williams at the moment. But it’s justified! In this novel, she has managed, once again, to create characters that I’d love to go out and have a drink with.
This story, which takes place in New York just as the world is reeling from the effects of the first World War, weaves together the lives of Sophie, a reclusive innocent who secretly tinkers with “machines”, Octavian, a WWI air force veteran/hero, and Theresa, a middle aged NYC socialite. As their lives become entangled, we gradually learn why Sophie’s life has been so sheltered by her father and how complications of love can bring out both evil and good.
Williams’ use of different voices enables her to truly uncover the personalities of her colorful and complex characters. We hear from Theresa in first person – and her aggressive but coy and sardonic humor shines through. On the other hand, we learn about Sophie in third person, but this is fitting as she actually knows little about herself, having been sheltered by her father and trying to break out. And with each change of perspective comes a different tint in language and feeling.
What is also amusing is that all of Williams’ books either centrally or peripherally involve the Schuyler family of Manhattan, her fabricated, very large and very intriguing family of characters. In this book we get to know Julie Schuyler, who is rich and confident and worldly, but also admittedly dependent on her family for her fun – a woman typical of her wealthy 1920’s era. She is a side character here, but serves as the vehicle that brings Sophie into the limelight of the story.
I can’t wait to read my next Beatriz Williams book!
It is the late 1960’s and Frankie has just moved to Palo Alto with her husband and two children. While her husband has found his dream job, her own dream of going to college and becoming a writer has gone unfulfilled. That is, until she meets the “Wednesday Sisters.” While watching her children play in a park near her new home, she meets a group of women who become her closest friends, her confidantes, and her literary critics! And as the 60’s roll into the 70’s, they see each other through their writing struggles as well as their personal struggles, and they evolve with women all over the country, supporting each other as they each begin to pursue their own interests and passions just as their husbands have done.
This is a sweet story, with the 1960’s as a subtle backdrop. The women have a wonderful relationship and bring out the best in each other. The respect that they show for each other, in spite of their individual quirks and conflicts, is what most would aspire to in a friendship and their solidarity, expressed most fully at the end (I won’t spoil it for you!) is truly beautiful. It is a little far-reaching as “realistic” goes, but it works anyway.
A fun, mostly light read… definitely a chick book!
For each of the 3 families attending the BBQ hosted by Tiffany and Vin, life was permanently altered. Clementine and Sam were unsure if their marriage would survive, Tiffany and Vin were not sure what was going on with their daughter, Dakota, and Erika could not remember a slice of time during the BBQ and was obsessively trying to recover that memory. Life seemed so simple before the BBQ. Things were taken for granted…
The beauty of this book is in the skillful crafting of the narrative, which circles around the BBQ and only very gradually divulges exactly what happened and how. By rotating around the characters’ perspectives and by weaving in and out of time frames, Moriarty builds up the suspense and enriches the impact of the crescendo of the story. And on the way down, she continues to add smaller punches which ultimately tie in each of the pieces of the puzzle.
I also love the message in this book, which is, essentially, that issues that are difficult or painful should be talked through. Keeping secrets and holding things inside only lead to repression and misperceptions, usually resulting in unfounded guilt or other sources of misery. Especially with children.
I am a big fan of Liane Moriarty – and this is yet another engaging, well-spun tale by her!
In the past, Stevie has coped with her life stress by eating – and this brought her to being 170 lbs overweight and to having a heart attack at the age of 32. She’s now had her stomach stapled and has lost the weight. Unfortunately, she still has not confronted her demons and her nightmares continue as do her shyness and her fear of speaking her mind. Fortunately, she has her cousins who love and support her, although they too are coping with shared trauma. This story is the tale of how Stevie finally confronts her fears and begins to take back her life.
The theme of the story is interesting, and some of the scenes are very poignant. There is stark portrayal of mental illness and how it affects everyone around them. The scenes with Stevie’s mother are particularly heartbreaking, as she has raging auditory and visual hallucinations and severe paranoia. This is the valuable part of the book.
On the other hand, the writing is so poor that it was hard to actually enjoy this book, and it seemed to deteriorate as the book progressed. It was almost as if the author herself tired of the book and just didn’t care anymore about how it was written – just had to finish it already! Things worked out too perfectly, characters were unidimensional and flat, dialogue was inane. Even basic grammar was sort of thrown to the wind. Sad, just sad.
So, all in all, it was actually a bit painful in many respects – not worth the time it took to read it. A good idea, but not at all well-executed.
By the way, I found this book via Bookbub, a daily email notification of the books that are on sale on the Kindle. I’ve found a few good books this way – I highly recommend this resource! Unfortunately, this wasn’t the best find on the email…