It is clear that Kristin Hannah’s writing blossomed dramatically between writing this novel and writing her master work The Nightingale. I was hoping to be drawn into similarly beautifully drawn scenes with intricate plot lines as I was in that great novel – and I was sorely disappointed here. While there started to be an intriguing idea for the story, and it began well enough, it just was not developed with the same sophistication and elegance as that later work.
This story begins with young Bret preparing the saddle early in the morning for his mom, Mikaela, to have her early morning horseback ride. Suddenly, something was noticeably off and Bret watched as his mom started jumped the horse and the horse stopped and Mikaela was thrown forward, banging her head against a pole, sustaining a severe head injury. The next thing they all knew, their lives were thrown upside-down, as Mikaela was in a deep coma and it was unclear if she’d ever recover. What comes after tests the love each of the family members has for each other.
There are some truly brilliant moments in this story and the basic plot is a clever one. The test of love that Mikaela’s husband, Liam, faces is a fascinating ethical dilemma that I think many would find paralyzingly difficult. And there are tender scenes between the various family members that are quite sweet.
However, the writing itself is somewhat simplistic. The plot could be more involved, with more story lines woven into the main one. The characters could be much more multi-dimensional – they are extremely flat – and, wow, is the latter half of the story just pure saccharine-sweetness! It felt as if the author herself got bored with the book about halfway through and just wanted to be over and done with the project, so she wrote whatever came out easily. It was quite anti-climactic.
So, stick with The Nightingale, and forget about this one, I’d say…
This is a book where writing is beautiful in its simplicity. Mma Ramotswe is the first lady detective in Botswana, fulfilling both hers and her father’s dream of owning her own business successfully. Although she is off to a precarious start, and has to take on occasionally less desirable cases (involving dogs, for example), she always uses her wise intuition and her cunning instincts to outsmart even the shadiest of characters. And as we hear her cases unfold, we also get a taste of Africa, which is as rich an experience as the stories themselves.
Between the twists and turns of the story lines, the beautiful and colorful characters and the rich landscape in which the events unfold, this book is absolutely delightful. I have seen it advertised for so many years and have not known what I’ve been missing all this time! I now find myself wanting to read the other sequels to this to see what other adventures await.
I highly recommend this to all of you as well. In this time of political distress, and when the news is so oppressively sad, this is a beautiful distraction.
Ava is still feeling raw, even a year after her husband has left her for a woman who is famous for “yarning” statues and signs. Thank goodness for her new book club, which has let her join for the new year. Unfortunately, in her yearning to be accepted, she has sworn that she’d procure the author of her book to appear at their meeting at the end of the year – and it just might take the whole year to find this obscure author!
At first glance, this book appears to be a somewhat superficial novel – but it very quickly delves beneath the surface, plunging into Ava’s traumatic childhood, and focusing also on her daughter, Maggie, who is lost and has lost herself in Paris. While there is not much discussion about feelings, there is much that is clearly felt, and the awkward moments are palpable in this book. Maggie’s character, in particular, is extremely poignant and sympathetic, and I felt very drawn to her. The change in voice from Ava’s to Maggie’s also helps to deepen the complexity of the plot and help move the story line along as well. It is quite suspenseful in some parts, especially when it comes to Maggie, as she engages in some very dangerous behaviors.
Spoiler alert: Don’t read the next paragraph if you don’t want to know my opinion about the ending…
Because my opinion is that the very ending is unfortunate. The book is actually quite good. I am not sure, however, why authors feel compelled to wrap their productions in such neat packages. Life isn’t like that so why do stories have to be? Even if the book had been as it is right up until the second to last page, it would have been ok. But literally the last 2 pages undid the book for me – just sent it right down the path to cheesy. Such a disappointment…
But overall, I’d still recommend this book – it’s a solid read and very engaging. And I personally enjoyed the location – as most of it took place in my original home town of Providence, RI – which does not happen very often!
Anna, Kate and George (short for Georgianna) could not be more different from each other – and yet, they inexplicably become fast friends in their college dorm. Unfortunately, life moves them beyond their usual frolicking to a shared traumatic experience that alters the trajectory of their respective life journeys.
I should have loved this book. It had all the right elements. I loved the characters. They were colorful, complicated, and clever. I liked the overall story and the intertwining of events. There were multiple layers of stories, which kept things interconnected and engaging. And the dialogue was witty and occasionally made me giggle out loud.
The problem was that it was extremely choppy. I love when the voice changes or the time changes – but the transitions must be smooth so as not to lose the reader. It was not done smoothly here. Every time a new chapter started, I felt like I was starting a new book over again – just with the same characters. There were such different scenes in such different locations with the characters in such different times of their lives, that it took a long time to figure out where we were in the story and how this part connected to the whole. I feel as the reader, I should definitely not have to work that hard.
Ultimately, though, I am glad I read this book – I did like it overall. I’d love to know what others think!
This is an example of a great idea poorly executed.
Paul is a successful writer of food and wine books who has just been jilted by his girlfriend of 4 years. In a bit of depression and in a rut, his agent (who of course, happens to be single, intelligent, and attracted to him) sends him to Italy to work on his next book. In a bizarre set of circumstances, he ends up with a rented bulldozer as his means of rented transportation during his stay. On his first foray to explore his new town, he happens upon a beautiful, intelligent woman who has run her car into a ditch and lo and behold (!) a bulldozer just might do the trick!
There are a few tiny plot strands that are started in this book that could make the book so interesting that unfortunately are never pursued. There is the evil-looking man that Paul is jailed with on entering the country (yes, jailed!), there is the boyfriend of the beautiful woman who has a port wine stain, and there are other towns folk who might be more involved in a more interesting plot than they are. But no, the author chooses to make his former girlfriend as truly shallow and predictable as she is (then why would he have spent the past 4 years with her??), and the ending as neat and predictable as it becomes.
There is so much potential here. I did finish it, but I spent most of the book waiting for something of substance to happen. I think I’m still waiting…
This was a sweet story about Josie, the owner of a bed and breakfast, whose Christmas holiday is off to a crazy start with her friend having a heart attack in the middle a bridge game in her home. This reminder of the vulnerability of life triggers her to invite her estranged daughters to come home for Christmas, much to their surprise, and it invites a lot of nostalgia mixed with emotional eruptions.
I think I’d describe this book as benign; it’s a decent read, quick, keeps one’s interest, the characters are likable, the writing is passable – but there is nothing imaginative about it. I did not learn anything new from it. There was nothing culturally unusual about it.
I do find stories about relationships interesting – mother/daughter, wife/husband, generational conflicts, etc. This touches on some of this. But I found that some of this is left undone, or kept at the surface. There is never a deep unpacking of the deeper relationship or feelings. There is never the huge explosion that there should be when emotions run so high.
I was left wanting just a little bit more. And in this case, that was not a good thing…
I love Liane Moriarty’s books – they’re fun, smart, and usually tackle topics of some substance. This book, unfortunately, is an exception…
Ellen is a hypnotherapist who prides herself in her work with people – she’s had many successful treatments, helping people in their relationships. Unfortunately, she has not had many successful relationships of her own; that is, until she meets Patrick. Patrick is handsome, kind, and fun – but complicated. He is a widower with a young son, which would be fine, if it weren’t for his stalker…
I think if the characters here were just a little more likable, or the story were a little more believable, or the substance of the book was a little more solid, it would have come together and been ok. But the characters were flat and strange, the story a bit outlandish, and the substance just too airy for my liking.
It wasn’t a book I gave up on, but it did feel just too long and I was glad to reach the end. Not a rave review, this time. Sorry!